The Filing Desk

First Internet Bancorp

INBK · Nasdaq · Financials · Financials, fiscal 2016 to 2025

INBK · Last close · November 19, 2026
$24.82
Value First Internet Bancorp yourself

First Internet Bancorp's revenue fell 13.6% to $116 million in fiscal 2025. Net income was −$35 million, down 239.1%. Its return on equity was −9.5%, down from 6.8% a year earlier. Its efficiency ratio was 81.6%, up from 66.9% a year earlier. It paid out $3 million in dividends and buybacks. The diluted share count fell 0.4%.

First Internet Bancorp Latest fiscal year ended December 31, 2025 10-K filed March 11, 2026 · 0001562463-26-000022 Updated
Revenue
$116M
13.6%
Net income
−$35M
239.1%
Return on equity
−9.5%
16.2 pts
Return on tangible equity
−9.6%
16.4 pts
Efficiency ratio
81.6%
14.7 pts
Market cap
$221M
Nov 19 close
P/E
14.6x
On $1.70 EPS, 4 qtrs

Return on equity is net income as a share of shareholders' equity; return on tangible equity leaves out goodwill and other intangible assets. The efficiency ratio is operating costs as a share of revenue, so lower means the bank spends less to earn each dollar. Market cap is the last closing share price times the latest diluted share count, so it is approximate. P/E is the last close divided by diluted earnings per share over the last four quarters, or the latest fiscal year where the quarters aren't available; there is none when the company made a loss.

Charts show fiscal years, from the 10-K filings.

Income statement

Revenue and net income
US$ billions, fiscal years; net losses in red. Revenue on the left axis, net income on the right; zero is the same line on both. Revenue is net of interest expense.
Revenue (left axis)Net income (right axis)
Efficiency ratio and net interest income
Percent of revenue. The efficiency ratio is noninterest expense over revenue.
Efficiency ratioNet interest income share

From fiscal 2016 to 2024, earnings per share grew 2.9% a year and net income 9.7% a year, as new shares raised the share count by 69% and diluted each share's earnings. First Internet Bancorp then lost money in fiscal 2025.

Diluted earnings per share
US$ per share, fiscal years, restated for any stock splits; loss years in red.

Return on equity

Return on equity
Percent. Net income over average equity; tangible equity excludes goodwill, intangibles and preferred stock.
Return on equityReturn on tangible common equity

Balance sheet

Loans and deposits
US$ billions, at each fiscal year end
Loans, netDeposits
Total assets and shareholders' equity
US$ billions, at each fiscal year end. Assets on the left axis, equity on the right.
Total assets (left axis)Equity (right axis)

Five years at a glance

Fiscal year endFY21FY22FY23FY24FY25
Loans, net2,8603,4683,8014,1263,691
Deposits3,1793,4414,0674,9334,840
Loans to deposits90.0%100.8%93.5%83.6%76.3%
Provision for credit losses15171772
Provision to average loans0.0%0.2%0.5%0.4%1.9%
Total assets4,2114,5435,1685,7385,572
Shareholders' equity380365363384360
US$ millions unless stated, at each fiscal year end.

Cash flow

Stock-based compensation and buybacks
US$ billions, fiscal years. Shares paid to employees (stock-based compensation, a cost that uses no cash) against cash spent buying shares back. Buybacks that only match it leave the share count roughly where it was.
Stock-based compensationShare buybacks
Dividends and buybacks
US$ billions, cash paid in each fiscal year
DividendsShare buybacks
Diluted share count
Weighted-average diluted shares, millions

Projections

Project First Internet Bancorp's revenue, net income and earnings per share five years ahead in a bull, a base and a bear case with your own figures, and see the share prices your P/E estimates give them. Every projected figure is yours: it is not a forecast of ours.

Insider trades

Over the 12 months between November 20, 2025 and November 19, 2026, 1 insider bought $19,830 of First Internet Bancorp shares on the open market, and none sold any.

Buys and sells by month
US$ millions, open-market purchases (up) and sales (down) by officers, directors and 10% owners in each month.
BoughtSold
DateInsiderTradeSharesPriceValueFiling
Feb 24, 2026Joseph A. FenechDirectorBought1,000$19.83$19,830Form 4
Open-market purchases and sales by officers, directors and 10% owners, from their Form 4 filings with the SEC: one row per person, day and filing, at the day's average price. Grants, option exercises and shares withheld for tax aren't counted. Insiders buy and sell for many reasons, such as taxes, spreading their savings or a plan set up months earlier, so a trade on its own says little about where a company is heading. For information only, not investment advice. Insider trades at all companies

Compare

Put First Internet Bancorp side by side with any other company we cover: revenue, growth, margins, cash flow and returns, with ten years of charts.

Similar companies

CompanyYearRevenue growthNet marginReturn on equityReturn on tangible equityEfficiency ratioCompare
First Internet BancorpFY25−13.6%−30.2%−9.5%−9.6%81.6%
PCB BancorpFY2516.1%32.4%9.9%12.0%51.2%Compare
Southern First BancsharesFY2526.5%25.7%8.7%8.7%64.0%Compare
Citizens Financial ServicesFY2510.3%32.5%11.5%15.9%57.6%Compare
Farmers & Merchants BancorpFY2519.6%27.4%9.4%12.3%63.3%Compare
Each company's latest fiscal year. Fiscal years end in different months, so the periods don't line up exactly.

10 years of figures

Fiscal yearFY16FY17FY18FY19FY20FY21FY22FY23FY24FY25
Income statement
Revenue54647180101119118101135116
Revenue growth31.5%20.0%10.1%12.3%26.5%18.4%−0.9%−14.6%33.4%−13.6%
Net interest income405462636487977587114
Noninterest income141091736332126473
Noninterest expense32374347586273799095
Provision for credit losses4546915171772
Net income12152225304836825−35
Diluted EPS (US$)2.302.132.302.512.994.823.700.952.88−4.03
Diluted shares (millions)571010101010999
Payouts
Dividends paid1222222222
Share buybacks000100428900
Balance sheet at fiscal year end
Loans, net1,2402,0762,6982,9423,0302,8603,4683,8014,1263,691
Deposits1,4632,0852,6713,1543,2713,1793,4414,0674,9334,840
Total assets1,8542,7683,5424,1004,2464,2114,5435,1685,7385,572
Shareholders' equity154224289305331380365363384360
Ratios
Return on equity9.3%8.1%8.5%8.5%9.3%13.5%9.5%2.3%6.8%−9.5%
Return on tangible common equity9.7%8.3%8.7%8.6%9.4%13.7%9.7%2.3%6.8%−9.6%
Return on assets0.8%0.7%0.7%0.7%0.7%1.1%0.8%0.2%0.5%−0.6%
Efficiency ratio58.5%56.9%60.8%58.5%57.1%51.8%61.9%78.6%66.9%81.6%
US$ millions unless stated. Where a later 10-K restated a year, the latest filed figure is shown. Download all figures (CSV, US$ millions)
Source: First Internet Bancorp's Form 10-K filings, from SEC EDGAR. For information only, not investment advice. The Filing Desk is not affiliated with First Internet Bancorp.