The Filing Desk

Amerisafe vs NI Holdings

Amerisafe AMSF · NI Holdings NODK · Property & Casualty Insurance

Amerisafe reported revenue of $317 million in fiscal 2025, about the same as NI Holdings' $285 million in fiscal 2025. Amerisafe's revenue grew 2.7% in its latest year, and NI Holdings' fell 12.3%. Free cash flow was $9 million at Amerisafe and −$15 million at NI Holdings.

Side by side

AmerisafeNI Holdings
Latest fiscal yearFY2025, Dec 31, 2025FY2025, Dec 31, 2025
Revenue$317M$285M
Revenue growth2.7%−12.3%
Revenue growth a year, last 5 years−1.3%−1.4%
Gross margin—24.5%
Operating margin——
Net margin14.9%−3.6%
Free cash flow$9M−$15M
Free cash flow margin2.8%−5.4%
Return on capital——
Net debt to EBITDA——
Dividends and buybacks$49M$7M
Change in diluted share count−0.4%−0.5%
Last close$18.90$14.74
P/E at the last close8.8×20.2×
Insider trades, last 12 monthssold $50,142—
Piotroski F-score——
Amounts in each company's own currency, US$ unless marked (a foreign company may report in another), each company's latest fiscal year from its 10-K, or 20-F or 40-F for a foreign company. Growth rates compare with the year before; the five-year rate is the average a year. Free cash flow is cash from operations minus capital spending; return on capital is after-tax operating income over the money invested in the business; P/E is the last close over the latest earnings per share. Banks are measured differently (return on equity, efficiency ratio), so some rows apply to one company only.

Ten years

Revenue
US$ billions, fiscal years
AmerisafeNI Holdings
Operating margin
Percent of revenue
AmerisafeNI Holdings
Free cash flow
US$ billions. Cash from operations minus capital expenditure.
AmerisafeNI Holdings

Start a new comparison

Source: the companies' Form 10-K filings, from SEC EDGAR, and the last close. For information only, not investment advice: the figures describe results, not which company is the better investment. The Filing Desk is not affiliated with either company. Full figures on the Amerisafe and NI Holdings pages.