The Filing Desk

Selective Insurance Group vs White Mountains Insurance Group

Selective Insurance Group SIGI · White Mountains Insurance Group WTM · Property & Casualty Insurance

Selective Insurance Group reported revenue of $5.3 billion in fiscal 2025, 1.4 times White Mountains Insurance Group's $3.7 billion in fiscal 2025. Selective Insurance Group's revenue grew 9.8% in its latest year, and White Mountains Insurance Group's grew 66.8%.

Side by side

Selective Insurance GroupWhite Mountains Insurance Group
Latest fiscal yearFY2025, Dec 31, 2025FY2025, Dec 31, 2025
Revenue$5.3B$3.7B
Revenue growth9.8%66.8%
Revenue growth a year, last 5 years12.8%33.1%
Gross margin—95.9%
Operating margin——
Net margin8.7%29.6%
Free cash flow$1.2B—
Free cash flow margin22.4%—
Return on capital14.6%20.9%
Net debt to EBITDA0.3x0.5x
Dividends and buybacks$186M$205M
Change in diluted share count−0.3%0.1%
Last close$102.71$2,222.50
P/E at the last close12.3×5.9×
Insider trades, last 12 monthsbought $50,886, sold $2.1 millionsold $10.8 million
Piotroski F-score——
Amounts in each company's own currency, US$ unless marked (a foreign company may report in another), each company's latest fiscal year from its 10-K, or 20-F or 40-F for a foreign company. Growth rates compare with the year before; the five-year rate is the average a year. Free cash flow is cash from operations minus capital spending; return on capital is after-tax operating income over the money invested in the business; P/E is the last close over the latest earnings per share. Banks are measured differently (return on equity, efficiency ratio), so some rows apply to one company only.

Ten years

Revenue
US$ billions, fiscal years
Selective Insurance GroupWhite Mountains Insurance Group
Operating margin
Percent of revenue
Selective Insurance GroupWhite Mountains Insurance Group
Free cash flow
US$ billions. Cash from operations minus capital expenditure.
Selective Insurance GroupWhite Mountains Insurance Group

Start a new comparison

Source: the companies' Form 10-K filings, from SEC EDGAR, and the last close. For information only, not investment advice: the figures describe results, not which company is the better investment. The Filing Desk is not affiliated with either company. Full figures on the Selective Insurance Group and White Mountains Insurance Group pages.